AI generated cartoon image of a storefront with confusing signage

Is Your Website Pushing Customers Away? 5 Fixable Mistakes Small Businesses Make

Let’s be real for a second…

Most small business owners I work with on Cape Cod don’t sit around thinking about their websites. They’re busy running their businesses—answering phones, scheduling jobs, juggling staff, and trying to have something that resembles a life.

So it makes sense that your website might have slipped into “set it and forget it” mode. But here’s the problem: while you’re focusing on everything else, your website might be quietly driving people away.

The good news? You probably don’t need a full redesign. A few small fixes can make a big difference. Here are five common website problems small business owners face and how to fix them.


1. Outdated Website Content? Why Fresh Info Builds Trust

You wouldn’t leave a faded “Grand Opening” banner up for five years, right? But that’s essentially what happens when your website hasn’t been updated in ages.

Common signs your site might be gathering dust:

  • Your homepage mentions services you no longer offer
  • Your last blog post was in 2019
  • Broken links or images that no longer load
  • A footer that still says “Copyright 2020”

This kind of stuff might seem small, but to a potential customer, it can scream “Are they even still in business?”

Quick Fix:

Set a calendar reminder to review your website every few months. Even 15–30 minutes of cleanup—updating services, replacing outdated images, checking links—can go a long way toward building trust.


2. Website Navigation Confusing Visitors? Fix These 2 Issues

Most people decide whether they’ll stick around your site in just a few seconds. If they can’t find what they’re looking for, they’re gone—and probably off to a competitor.

Two common navigation fails I see all the time:

  • Overcomplicated menus: You don’t need twelve dropdowns and five sub-menus. Keep it simple. Too many choices lead to decision fatigue.
  • “Creative” labels: Cute menu titles like “Our World” instead of “About Us” might feel fun, but they confuse new visitors.

The goal of your navigation is clarity, not creativity.

Quick Fix:

Stick to the classics: Home, About, Services, Contact. If you offer more than one service, consider a dropdown—but only if each item is truly necessary.

Bonus tip: Try asking a friend or customer to find something on your site. If they get lost, so will your visitors.


3. Is Your Website Mobile-Friendly? Here’s Why It Matters

More than 60% of website traffic comes from mobile devices. If your site only works well on a laptop, you’re leaving money on the table.

Warning signs your site isn’t mobile-ready:

  • Text is tiny or hard to read without zooming
  • Buttons are too small to tap easily
  • Images don’t resize correctly on phones
  • Key content is cut off or hidden

Not only is this frustrating for users, but Google also considers mobile-friendliness when ranking sites. So it’s a customer experience and SEO issue.

Quick Fix:

Check your site on your own phone. Tap through every page. Ask yourself:

  • Can I read the content easily?
  • Can I click buttons or links without pinching and zooming?
  • Would I be willing to use this site if I were in a hurry?

If it feels clunky, it’s time for a mobile tune-up.


4. Slow Website Speed? How to Make It Load Faster

A slow site is like a slow cashier—people get frustrated and walk away.

Common causes of sluggish load times:

  • Images that are way too large (think multi-megabyte files)
  • Too many WordPress plugins bogging things down
  • Cheap or overcrowded hosting

Speed isn’t just about convenience—it affects SEO rankings and bounce rates. If your site takes more than 3 seconds to load, you’re likely losing visitors.

Quick Fix:

  • Use a free tool like PageSpeed Insights to check your site’s performance.
  • Compress large images (tools like TinyPNG are great for this).
  • Deactivate and delete unused plugins on WordPress.
  • If your hosting is super slow, consider upgrading—it might cost a little more, but it can make a big difference.

5. Missing a Clear Call to Action on Your Website? Fix It Fast

Here’s a common mistake: a small business site that lists services, shows some photos, and then… nothing.

No “Call Now,” no “Request a Quote,” no form to fill out—just a dead end. Even if people are impressed by what they see, they don’t know what to do next.

Remember: Your website isn’t just a digital brochure. It’s a tool to get people to take action.

Quick Fix:

Make sure every page has a clear and specific call to action:

  • Want them to call you? Add a big, easy-to-click phone number.
  • Booking appointments? Add a “Schedule Now” button.
  • Offering estimates? Add a short contact form with a “Request a Quote” headline.

Repeat your CTA in more than one place—especially near the top and bottom of your most-visited pages.


A Little Website First Aid Can Go a Long Way

You don’t need to overhaul your whole site to get better results. Fixing a few common problems—stale content, poor mobile experience, slow load time, clunky menus, or unclear CTAs—can have a huge impact on how customers see you online.

And if you’re not sure where to start, that’s where I come in. I specialize in giving small, budget-friendly updates to websites that just need a little help—not a full rebuild.

Need a quick website checkup? Get in touch with me here and I’ll help you figure out what’s working—and what’s not.